Thoughts Of The Moment from Katie's Dad

Name:
Location: Near Reading, Pennsylvania, United States

"Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Day Break

An open letter I sent to ABC:

"Concerning Day Break ..... You guys suck! Maybe I shouldn't watch Lost when it returns. You might cancel that too.Merry Christmas"

The nerve of these guys. Get you to watch a show with a story arc. Than cancel it before you are half way thru. First they said they would pull it after this week. That was the last episode until after X-mas. Now they aren't even going to show that! We get George Lopez reruns instead.

I think this has to signal a change at the networks. The big serial drama experiment is now officially a failure. With Surface and Invasion failing to get a second season, and now Smith, Kidnapped, The Nine, Six Degrees, and Day Break all failing to finish one, I think we can look for the networks to try something different next season. And hey, if Diggs really wants to be on a hit show, they're still casting for the next Dancing with the Stars, right?... Too soon?

Thanks for the present ABC. Merry Christmas to you too .....

RIP, Maj. Megan McClung

I was reading The Huffington Post yesterday and came upon this tribute to Maj. Megan McClung. She has become the highest ranking woman killed in Iraq. I was hoping to just post the video but I couldn't. So below is a link.

In this holiday season we should all take time to remember the fallen. Whether you support the war or not think of those families who will spend Christmas without a loved one this year. Father, mother .... Husband, wife .... And maybe the hardest of all a child.

So please watch the video and think of them all.

McClung's father:

"We know that Megan died doing just what she wanted to do and we supported her all the way. It is a shame that I cannot share all of the tributes with each of you, but if I could, you would realize very quickly what a wonderful person Megan was. Her credo as a PAO was: "Be Bold, Be Brief, Be Gone!" She lived her credo to the end."

RIP, Maj. Megan McClung

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Old Abe and Our Times

I just finished reading "Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln" by Doris Kearns Goodwin. This is a great book for anybody who even remotely enjoys history or politics. I though I would read some here and there but I couldn't put it down. I was even kinda sad when he was assassinated .... Like I didn't know it was coming.

It just made me wonder were all the great leaders have gone. He went against everything his advisers and Congress was telling him. He did what he thought was right and what, in most cases, the people wanted.

We could use a little of that today!

Monday, December 04, 2006

War Quote of the Day

I was reading some older Thomas Friedman columns yesterday. Out of the three or four that I read one sentence stood out. Thing is it was the first sentence of the first column.

"The truth about Iraq today: This country is so broken it can't even have a proper civil war".

To me that just says it all!

"Ten months or ten years ?

THE truth about Iraq today: This country is so broken it can't even have a proper civil war.
There are so many people killing so many other people for so many different reasons — religion, crime, politics — that all the proposals for how to settle this problem seem laughable. It was possible to settle Bosnia's civil war by turning the country into a loose federation, because the main parties to that conflict were reasonably coherent, with leaders who could cut a deal and deliver their faction.
But Iraq is in so many little pieces now, divided among warlords, foreign terrorists, gangs, militias, parties, the police and the army, that nobody seems able to deliver anybody. Iraq has entered a stage beyond civil war — it's gone from breaking apart to breaking down. This is not the Arab Yugoslavia anymore. It's Hobbes' jungle.
We need to face real choices in Iraq: 10 months or 10 years. Either we get out of Iraq in a phased withdrawal over 10 months, and try to stabilize it some other way, or we accept that the only way it will not be a failed state is if we start over and rebuild it, which would take 10 years. This would require reinvading Iraq, with at least 150,000 more troops, crushing the Sunni and Shiite militias, controlling borders, and building Iraq's institutions and political culture.
Anyone who tells you we can train a few more Iraqi troops and police officers and then slip out in two or three years is either lying or a fool. The minute we would leave, Iraq would collapse. There is nothing we can do by the end of the Bush presidency that would produce a self-sustaining stable Iraq.
In his must-read new book about the impact of culture on politics and economic development, "The Central Liberal Truth," Lawrence Harrison notes that some cultures are "progress-prone" and others are "progress-resistant." In the Arab-Muslim world today the progress-resistant cultural forces seem to be just too strong, especially in Iraq, which is why it is so hard to establish durable democratic institutions in that soil, he says.
"Some may hark back to our successful imposition of democracy on West Germany and Japan after World War II," adds Harrison. "But the people on whom democracy was imposed in those two countries were highly literate and entrepreneurial members of unified, institutionalized societies with strong traditions of association — what we refer to today as 'social capital.' Iraq was social capital-poor to start with and it now verges on bankruptcy."
On Feb. 12, 2003, I wrote a column offering what I called my "pottery store" rule for Iraq: "You break it, you own it." (Colin Powell later used the phrase to get Bush to act with more caution, but he did not heed Powell's advice.)
But my Pottery Barn rule was wrong, because Iraq was already pretty broken before we got there. It was held together only by Saddam's iron fist. Had we properly occupied the country, and begun political therapy, it is possible an American iron fist could have held Iraq together long enough to put it on a new course. But instead we created a vacuum by not deploying enough troops.
That vacuum was filled by murderous Sunni Baathists and al-Qaida types, who butchered Iraqi Shiites until they finally wouldn't take it any longer and started butchering back, which brought us to where we are today. The Sunni Muslim world should hang its head in shame for the barbarism it has tolerated and tacitly supported by the Sunnis of Iraq, whose violence, from the start, has had only one goal: America must fail in its effort to bring progressive politics or democracy to this region. America must fail — no matter how many Iraqis have to be killed, America must fail.
This has left us with two impossible choices. If we're not ready to do what is necessary to crush the dark forces in Iraq and properly rebuild it, then we need to leave — because to just keep stumbling along as we have been makes no sense. It will only mean throwing more good lives after good lives into a deeper and deeper hole filled with more and more broken pieces".


Thomas Friedman writes for the New York Times.

New York Times